Is Climate Change really as bad as scientists claim it is? Will it not be nice to have a few degrees warmer? Will our planet really be different? How fast? Why?

About 20 years ago, I decided to dig a bit deeper in the science of Climate Change to learn what this climate change malarkey was all about:

This is what I learned:

This is the graph from the nineties that triggered my curiosity. It explains the different scenarios of Graphfuture warming, depending on unpredictable variables, including our human behaviour in reducing greenhouse emissions.

What was clear to me from this graph is that whatever we do, the temperature was going up. The only variable was the steepness of the incline. My interested was triggered.

Then I learned about James Lovelock and his Gaia Theory: The Gaia theory proposes that organisms interact with their inorganic surroundings on Earth to form a self-regulating, complex system that helps  maintain the conditions for life on the planet. Topics of interest include how the biosphere and the evolution of life forms affect the stability of global temperature, ocean salinity, oxygen in the atmosphere and other environmental variables that affect the habitability of Earth.

In short, our planet is only habitable for us humans because of a complex mechanism of interactions which create the homeostasis of our biosphere and ecosystem.
Many of these interactions are described as feedback loops. Feedback loops are mechanisms that reinforce themselves. Example: The richer you are, the easier it is to make money. Or when we are talking about our biosphere:00 0001 1 (2)

In order to have a more or less stable balance, these feedback loops need to cancel each other out. Example: In the past, if a lot of C02 would be emitted for instance by a volcano eruption, plants and algae would grow faster and capture and store this CO2.

If the balance gets disturbed, the whole system becomes unstable and can rapidly accelerate into one extreme or another. In the case of the climate: into an ice age or a tropical ice free planet which is unable to sustain human life.

So that is what we need to try to avoid.

OOPS:

Today, it is clear that many of those feedback loops are increasing in strength. Some people say they are triggered, meaning that they are increasing in strength and are increasing warming of the planet.

Here are some of those feedback loops that are triggered already:

Positive feedback loops
Positive feedback loops

Other ones that are not widely recognised are:

A chaotic climate increases droughts, droughts increase the likelihood of forest fires, forest fires increase soot in the air, which has to come down, sometimes it colours Greenland black, which increases heat intake, which reduces reflection into space, which increases warming, and on it goes..
00 0001 1 (4)

Or this one:
arctic_2102835b

As the Arctic warms and has less ice, more oil becomes available to be pumped up, the more oil is available, the more we will burn…

It almost seems as if global warming is exponential. The warmer it gets, the faster it warms. This makes abrupt climate shifts more like a heart attack than like a chronic disease whose course can be extrapolated.

If this is happening right now, it must have happened before, right?
Indeed it has many times:
Dansgaard–Oeschger events are rapid climate fluctuations that occurred 25 times during the last glacial period. More on these here
Other examples can be found here.

And if this theory is indeed correct, this should be reflected in the predictions that were made 20 years ago?

Are they?
This is the graph from the nineties again, with the dot showing were we are right now: Plus 1°C above average.
00 0002 1 (8)

OOPS again.

 

Let this sink in for a minute. And then ask yourself these questions:

  • Should we try to stop it anyway, even if that seems futile?
  • Since it is happening so fast, will it seriously affect me or my kids or grand kids? How much?
  • What is the best course of action?

20 years ago I decided to change my life. To learn basic skills, like food growing, shelter building, and other essential aspects of Permaculture. Because whatever the odds, I want to be part of the solution.

Because if our species does have a future, the future is permaculture.

If you want to learn more about the science behind this post, I can highly recommend this book:

The Web Of Life
The Web Of Life (click to read a review)

When I read the Book The Web Of Life, by Fritjof Capra, I really understood the complex system of our climate. And most importantly, how bad the situation of climate change really was.